![]() |
Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
I was reading a Coin World July 3rd issue I believe, the mint was going to sell the proof gold buffaloes at 875.00 but gold had just dropped at decision time, so they went with $800.00.
I have a hunch that with gold rising, currently 668.00, the mint in their wisdom, (that is a joke, friends) will be "forced" to announce a higher price on new orders, as of a certain date. The article went on to say that 50,000+ were ordered first day. When you price a regular version currently at 710-725, (or 900 on the shopping channel) ...... these are a screaming buy... SELL some of that "precious" silver and get one...your downside risk is very minimal.....glta |
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
They really are a gorgeous piece.....I am glad they went with the actual 1913 Fraser Design and not that moth eaten design they put on the Jefferson nickel.
Some background on the Buffalo design....from U.S. Coin Encyclopedia The act of Sept 25th 1890 abolished the Three cent piece, gold dollar and 3 dollar gold piece. It also forbade design changes oftener than 25 years; ostensibly to deter counterfeiting of new types, but actually to discourage coin collectors. In 1911, the sec of the treasury was informed that during his term only one coin could be changed, the libery head nickel (first issued 1883). James Fraser was contacted and produced a pair of models in June of 1911. The obverse is a composite of three chiefs Iron Tail (Custers opponent at Little big horn), Two Moons, John Big Tree. The reverse is an American Bison ,Black Diamond living at that time, in central park zoo. What apparently stalled the release in 1912 was vending machine companies demands for design changes as the new coin would not pass counterfeit-detection devices...after much delay, the mint finally went with Frasers original design and told vending companies to change their apparatus After the Bison Black Diamond was slaughtered, the firm of A Silz sold the meat as "Black Diamond Steaks" at $2.00 a pound. The head was preserved and is privately owned. |
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
I saw one at the dealer today. $900 for a proof. Seems like a bunch, how sure are you collectors that these are a good buy?
I know very little about collectibles and would appreciate any help here. E-A |
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
Your downside is one ounce of pure gold.....glta
|
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
Just make sure that you choose the slow shipping. (It is a free automatic upgrade to expedited shipping if your order is over $300 or contains gold.)
Ebay sellers are selling these for at least 850 and up. |
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
I don't mean to rain on the parade, but this post is a bit misleading. I have a few numismatic coins because I like them.
But to say these are a bargain and a steal is not accurate. As gold price rises, the collectable value of a proof becomes less important, and you wont be able to get as high a premium above spot price. These coins are great, they are 1oz of gold at a very high price. Buy them if you like them. They are not rare as you can still line up and buy one. Whether its $100 over spot or $300 over spot - its still a lot over spot. You could also buy one as speculative because its the first year. But its purely speculative. The 1986 US Gold Eagle does not charge much over spot at UNC or PROOF. It can also be argued proof is good to buy when gold falls. If gold goes back to $550/oz, all proofs wil have to be cheaper than they are now. Just balancing out the view here :) We don't want people buying these because they think they will double in value or something. If you're just after % gain in your metals..bargain hunt UNC coins from any other major countries (usa, Sth Africa, Australia, Canada) |
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
Check this one out! Why is he getting such high bids? $4150 for the graded PCGS PF70 Gold Buffalo Proof
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll...MEWA%3AIT&rd=1 |
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
Quote:
Same reason someone got $4,400 for an MS70 version of the coin on Ebay when its normally going for about $1000-1200...........people with a lot more money than brains! "Humans - monkeys with carkeys and nukes!"....and too much money Ho! |
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
"Humans - monkeys with carkeys and nukes!"....and too much money
That will be good for those with these coins. Think I'll send mine off to PCGS and put em up on ebay then buy the regular bullion :rolleyes: |
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
Sid, I NEVER SAID THESE ARE A STEAL.....REREAD WHAT I SAID........the commercial uncs are 700+ for 800 you got the same ounce of 24kt and a proof limited edition.
If gold goes down to 550 your K-rands will be worth 540. The bullion strike Buffaloes will be worth 550-560. The proof Buffalo may not lose a cent as who is buying these to sell at a loss??? Collectors buy em and sit on them forever... Do not load up on anything without your own D.D. but if you are buying gold at 700+ why not add some Proofs at another $100.? GLTA |
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
Quote:
|
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
Mintages of the Australian Nuggett coins are restricted to:
350,000 1oz, 100,000 1/2oz, 150,000 1/4oz, 200,000 1/10oz, and 200,000 1/20oz coins From: http://lynncoins.com/kangaroo-nuggets.htm |
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
It's hard to go wrong buying the lower mintage fractionals, in this case the half and quarter ouncers. Most years, lower mintage pieces, Unc or Proof, tend to do better than the others. Just compare the price charts with the mintage figures. Problem is, especially with the unc. versions, is that you have no idea what the final mintage tally will be for a particular year. Unless of course the mintage limits are decided and announced ahead of time as in the case of the first year proofs.
I agree in principle with Bullionaire, that the little extra cost of the proofs (buy them "pre-certified" from Tulving or whomever) is well worth the added profit possibilities. Remember though, that with any "collectible".... they all filter back to the point of primary demand, and that is with the collector. If there are more coins than collectors, the price has little chance of sustainable gains beyond just speculation. FWIW |
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
No disrespect to Australia, (vacationed there last year , thumbs up to topless beaches) , Very Few people collect that lunar gold glop......very very very thin market...just because a coin has 100 produced, does not produce a rarity...there has to be a market base.
REREAD MY INITIAL POST...... if you are buying gold buffaloes at these levels, your risk is $100.00 period. I purchased mine as I am partial to the Early American classic designs, look at the beauty of early designs versus the crappy circulation designs. Once a collector always a collector.... With past criticism, the mint probably chose a mintage number to placate as many gold collectors as possible. They made 500,000 silver 2001 buffaloes and they could have sold another 500,000. glta |
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
Quote:
|
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
Quote:
You can not judge one by the other - and for a difference of $50 its worth it that it might skyrocket like some other proof coins have. |
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
Quote:
But I also figure the MS70 will, ultimately be worth as much or more.........the MS69 will be worth less than both. I have spoken with a dozen dealers and coin collectors who agreed with that before I bought (and no, I did not buy from them so they had no reason to say that - they knew they were not going to make a penny off of me.) |
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
Quote:
If it comes straight from the mint the odds are good it will grade at MS 69 or 70......... |
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
Quote:
|
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
Quote:
I think its very good, based on calls to NGC and PCGS - NGC is giving easier grades, if you have a choice, but most prefer PCGS, and they get a bit more for their coins.........the only problem is the gold at 24kt is a bit softer, but both companies say they have seen lots of MS 70's.........whats odd is - if you look on Ebay, there are lots of NGCs but very few PCGSs at MS 70 - I am not sure but it "feels" like someone is hoarding the MS70's. |
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
Quote:
Plus it is an Indian head those seem to much more collectable. |
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
Quote:
|
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
Quote:
My pleasure to share what I know - wish I knew more than I do - but good luck collecting and investing! Ho |
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
Quote:
I may be a collector but if I were to offer the average Joe on the road a PCGS MS70 slabbed proof buffalo for $670 they would say why would I want to spend that much on that coin? They have no idea what the spot price of gold is and could care less about an expensive disc of metal. The price of collectables is not only governed by supply and demand but also knowledge. I wear a 14k gold chain of which only 10 were made. Does that make it a huge collectible? In the eyes of someone who collects that jewelers merchandise, yes. But really how many people care about an obscure Rhodes jewelers rarities. It may be worth it's weight in gold but other than that due to other than that it's all a matter of whether or not the buyer knows or cares just how rare it is when thinking about buying it. For what it's worth I hope these do shoot through the roof, I have some on the way. |
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
I agree that the NGC graded PR70's may not be the better investment here. I have seen several NGC graded PR70 Gold Buffalos so far, especially on HSN and S@H and it's my opinion that probably 20% (MAX) of those would be given a 70 if PCGS had graded them. I don't know if the television networks have offered premiums for every highest grade certified or what (no allegations being made), but I know of many, MANY dealers that are lowering their faith in NGC's integrity on grading as a result. Bottom line, my purchase will be for PCGS graded 70's as these, in my opinion will be the true rarities and collectibiles with unquestionable integrity, and that is the only 'rarity' factor (again, in my opinion)! And I have no intent on 'loading up on them'. I think a couple added to the portfolio will be sufficient.
P.S. APMEX, COULD YOU PLEASE PROVIDE YOUR OPINION/THOUGHTS ON THIS ISSUE? THANKS. |
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
I don't know if you could consider a mintage of 300K "rare" but I question owning Gold coins minted by the most hated country on the planet. I'll stick with the Maple Leafs maybe pick up a Buffalo as a curiosity.
|
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
Quote:
The buffalos are not anything special in my humble opinion and if you are betting on their collectible value you better hope somebody is willing to be on the other side of a future transaction. |
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
Quote:
|
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
Alot of the high-end graded PCGS bullion filters through Tulving, as he submits HUGE quantities of newly minted U.S. bullion gold directly to PCGS when he receives it. He's close to PCGS headquarters, so has the opportunity to do so.
But what you will notice is that he is obviously shooting for the MS-70 and Proof-70 grades, because he literally dumps the 69 material back onto the market at very low premiums....... right now about $28 per coin over spot on cash deals. He even trades PCGS MS-69 slabbed Buffalos for Krugerrands, Maples, and other one ounce bullion coins for only $15 per coin on the trade. That barely covers the per-coin grading and slabbing fees involved. Those 70 grades is where he hits the jackpot, and where he makes his money on this stuff, looking to profit on perceived "grade rarity". None of this stuff is "rare" by any means. It's more a matter of getting the right coins in front of the graders and getting their blessing. NGC is getting too loose on their grading standards for 70 grades, while PCGS is still the service to go with on these top grades if that is what interests you. BUT, remember that there is not one person in a thousand that can "show" you the difference between an MS-69 and an MS-70 coin under magnification, even in the slab, regardless of which grading service they are from. |
Re: Load up on Proof Gold Buffaloes...NOW!!
The nice thing about the proofs is the mint limited a customer to 10 coins only and tried to distribute them as widely as possible. Not just to a few dealers who would have made all the cash. I am sending mine to PCGS to see what grade I can get. Hoping for PF70 first strike. That seems to be the one selling for the highest price.
|
| All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:15 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2010, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright = None use it and Link to GIM